shield7w.gif (2619 bytes)

ukems.gif (1582 bytes) United Kingdom Environmental Mutagen Society


OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS: Referee's Report Form

 

Title of Journal: MUTAGENESIS 

Authors/Title: ... 

Manuscript No:

Referee's No: -

(A) Comments to be transmitted to the author

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

(B) Confidential comments Signed:

A checked box signifies that you agree with the statement following. To indicate that you disagree with the statement, write NO or leave blank.

 

  This manuscript is suitable for inclusion   Could paper be shortened significantly without loss of clarity and effectiveness. If so indicate where in A above.
This manuscript would be suitable if the substantial alterations detailed above in section A are implemented. (I do/do not wish to see the revised Ms.) Assuming the manuscript in its original or revised form is scientifically acceptable give the paper a priority rating for inclusion on a scale of 1 (highest) to 5 (lowest).
  This manuscript is not suitable for inclusion for the reasons detailed above in section A.   Should the author wish to clarify any points raised, I would be prepared to have him/her communicate with me.
   Please return by     I would be prepared to see this manuscript again if the editor felt it necessary.

 


home.gif (1087 bytes) contents.gif (1130 bytes) feedback.gif (1155 bytes) search.gif (1078 bytes)

For further information contact: JMP@swansea.ac.uk
University of Wales Swansea